清代乾隆至咸丰年间,广东新会县赵、莫两姓争夺沙田数十年,期间赵姓家族通过伪造地契、篡改边界等不法手段,企图强行霸占,历任知县审断结果相互矛盾,导致冲突进一步扩大,最终引发大规模命案,知县聂亦峰审理案件时将赵姓通过诉讼谋取利益的行为总结为“图告不图审”五字,本文以赵莫两姓田坦案为中心,从制度、社会利益和司法实践等角度探讨“图告不图审”的地方诉讼特征成因及背后清代粤中地区基层司法与地方宗族权力网络的互动。
赵莫两姓田坦案;图告不图审;新会;土地纠纷
From the Qianlong to Xianfeng reigns of the Qing dynasty, the Zhao and Mo clans in Xinhui County, Guangdong, engaged in a decades-long struggle over sandbar fields (shatian). During this dispute, the Zhao clan sought to seize the land by illicit means, including forging deeds and altering boundary descriptions. Contradictory rulings by successive county magistrates exacerbated the conflict, ultimately leading to a massive and deadly clash. In trying the case, Magistrate Nie Yifeng characterized the Zhao clan’s pursuit of illicit gain through litigation as “filing lawsuits without seeking trial” (tu gao bu tu shen). Centering on the Zhao-Mo sandbar land dispute, this paper explores the institutional, socio-economic, and judicial factors behind this distinct local litigation ecology, illuminating the intricate interaction between grassroots judicial administration and local lineage power networks.
Qing Dynasty; Xinhui;Land Dispute
林嘉渠. 由新会赵莫两姓田坦案看粤中“图告不图审”的地方诉讼特征[J]. 人文与社会科学学刊. 2026, 2 (11): 74-78. DOI: 10.70693/202610168463.
林嘉渠. (2026). 由新会赵莫两姓田坦案看粤中“图告不图审”的地方诉讼特征. 人文与社会科学学刊, 2 (11), 74-78. https://doi.org/10.70693/202610168463