辛亥革命与二次革命在反对专断、维护共和的政治诉求上存在连续性,但两次行动所凭借的社会联盟与地方政治条件并不相同。辛亥时期,各省地方军事力量、革命党人、立宪派及绅商团体因反清目标而形成暂时联合;至1913年,围绕民初政争与战争风险,各方态度趋于分化,地方军政系统亦难以再次统一行动。列强对华政策及中央财政能力的变化,进一步影响了双方的力量对比。二次革命的失败并非辛亥革命历史意义的否定,而是揭示了废除帝制之后,共和制度仍须解决政治权威、地方利益与社会认同之间的复杂关系。
辛亥革命;二次革命;地方政治;社会动员;共和制度
The Revolution of 1911 and the Second Revolution of 1913 both used armed uprisings and provincial independence, yet ended differently. Why could the coalition that overthrew the Qing not be mobilized again against Yuan Shikai? Examining commercial associations, provincial military politics and diplomatic records, this article argues that opposition to the Qing briefly united disparate local actors in 1911. In 1913, merchants increasingly prioritized stability, provincial leaders disagreed over resistance, and foreign powers acted according to their own interests. The contrast marks a change in the conditions of political mobilization rather than the disappearance of republican aspirations. The Second Revolution exposed the difficulty of transforming an anti-dynastic coalition into institutions able to manage conflict within a republic.
Revolution of 1911; Second Revolution; political mobilization; provincial politics; republican institutions
武欣悦. 共和何以失守:辛亥革命与二次革命的动员机制及政治转折[J]. 人文与社会科学学刊. 2026, 2 (11): 237-241. DOI: 10.70693/202610164109.
武欣悦. (2026). 共和何以失守:辛亥革命与二次革命的动员机制及政治转折. 人文与社会科学学刊, 2 (11), 237-241. https://doi.org/10.70693/202610164109