在高校毕业生规模持续攀升与就业结构性矛盾并存的背景下,高职毕业生在学历层次、专业深度与社会认可度上相对弱势,其就业困境不仅源于岗位供给不足,更源于职业认知模糊与求职行动迟滞,传统就业指导对此回应有限。本研究以北京2024—2026年三期求职能力实训营118名学员为样本,采用前后测准实验与混合方法,评估政校企社协同实训效果及模式差异。结果:职业成熟度总分由169.34±22.51升至179.04±21.83(t=8.76,p<0.001,d=0.44),6/8维度显著改善。课程模式差异显著:产业导向型C营最优(d=0.734),认知建构型A营次之(d=0.486),技能扩展型B营最弱(d=0.312),差异集中于认知入口、行动深度、反馈来源与产业融入。基线效应显著(β=-0.486),低基线学员提升14.2分,高于高基线组5.3分;26.2%学员职业态度负向变化实为认知校准。建议构建“认知—行动—反馈”三重闭环,强化政校企社协同与分层干预。
求职能力训练营;职业成熟度;高职学生;课程模式差异;分层干预
Against the backdrop of continuously rising numbers of college graduates and coexisting structural employment contradictions, higher vocational college graduates are relatively disadvantaged in degree level, professional depth, and social recognition. Their employment difficulties stem not only from insufficient job supply but also from vague career cognition and delayed job-seeking actions, to which traditional employment guidance has limited response. This study takes 118 trainees from three job-seeking ability training camps held in Beijing from 2024 to 2026 as samples, and adopts a pretest-posttest quasi-experimental design and mixed methods to evaluate the intervention effects and model differences of government-school-enterprise-society collaborative training. Results: The total career maturity score increased from 169.34±22.51 to 179.04±21.83 (t=8.76, p<0.001, d=0.44), with 6 out of 8 dimensions significantly improved. Significant differences were found among curriculum models: the industry-oriented Camp C performed best (d=0.734), followed by the cognitive-constructive Camp A (d=0.486), and the skill-expansion Camp B was the weakest (d=0.312). Differences were concentrated in cognitive entry, action depth, feedback source, and industry immersion. The baseline effect was significant (β=-0.486); low-baseline trainees improved by 14.2 points, higher than the 5.3 points of the high-baseline group. The negative change in career attitude among 26.2% of trainees was actually cognitive calibration. It is recommended to build a threefold closed loop of “cognition–action–feedback” and strengthen government-school-enterprise-society collaboration and differentiated intervention.
job-seeking ability training camp; career maturity; higher vocational college students; curriculum model differences; differentiated intervention
王巧莲,郑振华,石玉峰. 产业导向与认知建构:三类求职能力实训营对高职学生职业成熟度的干预效果比较[J]. 人文与社会科学学刊. 2026, 2 (11): 130-136. DOI: 10.70693/202610145200.
王巧莲, 郑振华, 石玉峰. (2026). 产业导向与认知建构:三类求职能力实训营对高职学生职业成熟度的干预效果比较. 人文与社会科学学刊, 2 (11), 130-136. https://doi.org/10.70693/202610145200