当前位置:人文与社会科学学刊 > 2026年11月-2卷11期 > 文章详情
Open Access Crossmark - Check for updates
PDF 本期PDF

文化与制度之间: 钱穆《政学私言》中的五权宪制构想

Between Culture and Institution The concept of the five-power constitutional system in Qian Mu's "Private Remarks on Politics and Academia"

作者:刘展
单位:同济大学政治与国际关系学院
卷期:2026年11月-2卷11期
通讯作者:刘展
页码:207-213
发布时间:2026-11-10
总浏览量:221

摘要

五权宪法是孙中山对中国革命成功之后国家政体理论的设计,是重要的建国纲领,钱穆在《政学私言》中则提出了不同于孙中山五权宪法的五权宪制方案,试图在现代政治制度与中华传统文化之间架设桥梁。本文以钱穆与孙中山的五权宪制为中心对象,探讨两者在制度构想、文化取向与政治哲学上的差异。孙中山强调制度效率与民族治理,而钱穆更关注文化正当性与文明延续,以回应现代制度与传统道统之间的张力。同时钱穆五权宪制体现了中国式宪政思维的文化自觉,为儒家宪制的现代转化提供了重要思想资源,对当前中国法治与宪制发展具有重要启发意义。

关键词

钱穆;《政学私言》;五权宪制;孙中山;政治思想

Abstract

The Five-Power Constitution was Sun Yat-sen's design of the theory of the state political system after the success of the Chinese revolution and was an important program for nation-building. Qian Mu proposed a five-power constitutional system plan different from Sun Yat-sen's Five-Power Constitution in his "Private Remarks on Politics and Academia", attempting to build a bridge between modern political systems and traditional Chinese culture. This article takes the five-power constitutional system of Qian Mu and Sun Yat-sen as the central object to explore the differences between the two in terms of institutional conception, cultural orientation and political philosophy. Sun Yat-sen emphasized institutional efficiency and national governance, while Qian Mu was more concerned with cultural legitimacy and the continuation of civilization, in response to the tension between modern institutions and traditional moral traditions. At the same time, the five-power constitutional system of Qian and Mu embodies the cultural consciousness of Chinese-style constitutional thinking, providing important ideological resources for the modern transformation of Confucian constitutionalism and having significant enlightening significance for the current development of the rule of law and constitutional system in China.

Keywords

Qian Mu;"Private Remarks on Politics and Academia";Five-power constitutional system;Sun Yat-sen;Political thought

引用本文

刘展. 文化与制度之间: 钱穆《政学私言》中的五权宪制构想[J]. 人文与社会科学学刊. 2026, 2 (11): 207-213. DOI: 10.70693/202610116648.

APA引用

刘展. (2026). 文化与制度之间: 钱穆《政学私言》中的五权宪制构想. 人文与社会科学学刊, 2 (11), 207-213. https://doi.org/10.70693/202610116648

参考文献

[1]钱穆.《政学私言》[M].北京:九州出版社,2010:3.
[2]钱穆.《政学私言》[M].北京:九州出版社,2010:5.
[3]钱穆.《中国历代政治得失》[M].北京:三联出版社,2001:1.
[4]姚中秋.再思张君劢、钱穆之争:文明与宪制之辩[J].清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2017,32(02):15-25+197.
[5]钱穆.《政学私言》[M].北京:九州出版社,2010:5.
[6]钱穆.《政学私言》[M].北京:九州出版社,2010:4.
[7]任锋.钱穆的“明夷待访录”[J].政治思想史,2018,9(04):1-17+197.
[8]钱穆.《现代中国学术论衡》[M].北京:三联出版社,2001:5.
[9]易顶强,陈晓枫.《舶来的宪政文化:以“五权宪法”为例》[M].湖北武汉:武汉大学出版社,2013.
[10]孙中山.《孙中山全集》第6卷[M].北京:中华书局,1985:194-195.
[11]刘蕾.孙中山训政理论与中国宪政[J].常州工学院学报(社科版),2012,30(04):97-100.
[12]杨毓康.传统民本政治的近代转型——探析以“权能分职”为枢纽的五权宪制方案[J].中国政治学,2023,(02):73-93+135-136.
[13]钱穆.《政学私言》[M].北京:九州出版社,2010:9.
[14]胡云.风宪再造:钱穆政治思想中的监察权理论[J].政治思想史,2020,11(04):38-54+197-198.
[15]林绪武.孙中山五权宪法的“中西合璧”文化解读[J].广东社会科学,2013,(05):109-116.
[16]任锋.钱穆的法治新诠及其启示:以《政学私言》为中心[J].西南大学学报(社会科学版),2018,44(05):31-40+189
[17]姚中秋.再思张君劢、钱穆之争:文明与宪制之辩[J].清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2017,32(02):15-25+197.
CC BY 本文依据 知识共享署名 4.0 国际许可协议 授权发布。允许他人在署名原作者及来源的前提下复制、传播和使用本文。

编辑部微信

回到顶部